Last week, USA Today reported that bullying lawsuits are on the rise nationwide. The National School Boards Association is unaware of any formal studies, but says anecdotal evidence shows an obvious increase.
In Kentucky, there have been several lawsuits filed against school administrators and educators across the Commonwealth claiming that their failure to develop or implement proper bullying policies and procedures, or a failure to supervise students, leads to students being seriously injured by bullies, or, tragically, even taking their own lives - a term coined in the 1980's as "bullycide." As a mother of two boys, this is an area of the law I am particularly passionate about and have spent the last several years educating myself on the issue of bullying and what educators need to be doing to protect children and prevent such tragedies, since they are often in the best position to stop it.
While reports of suicides relating to bullying date back over 30 years, the tragedies have gained national media attention since the mass murder/suicide at Columbine High School in Littleton, Colorado in 1999. Most recently, the suicide of Phoebe Prince in Massachusetts after being bullied daily at her high school, shined a spotlight on children of "status" bullyers - i.e. athletes, wealthier children, children of prominent individuals in the community, etc.
Kentucky has yet to have a bullying lawsuit make it's way to trial and through our appellate courts, so how the Commonwealth's appellate courts will view school administrator and educator liability on the issue of school bullying has yet to be seen. But Kentucky's Supreme Court has published several cases on the issue of school officials' liability for injuries due to negligent supervision of students. Most recently in Turner v. Nelson, a case decided by the Kentucky Supreme Court in June, 2011, the court made clear that teachers are immune from liability for their discretionary acts in determining how to handle situations that may arise in their classroom if there is no set policy. However, the Court was also quick to point out that a failure to supervise children does not insulate teachers from liability for a child's injuries. Children must be supervised at all times - period. When they are not, we know from experience that bad things happen - including bullying.
Childhood bullying can lead to long-term physical and emotional harm. Often the scars of school bullying cannot be seen on the skin, but rather in the child's ability to relate to others and view themselves in a positive light as they grow into adulthood. No longer can we allow bullying to be viewed as a "rite of passage," "just kids being kids" or anything short of deadly.
It should not take a lawsuit to convince school systems to develop and implement strong bullying policies with regular outside evaluation of the policy's effectiveness, to supervise children at all times, and to take seriously reports of school bullying and act on them. Sadly, sometimes it does. I am proud to represent several families who have turned to the courts, and the citizens of Kentucky who serve on our juries, to decide what kind of conduct will and will not be tolerated in Kentucky's schools and who will be accountable when injuries result from such failures of school officials.